There's two that instantly come to mind for me.
One was Paulo Di Canio for Sheff Weds when they were 5 0 up at half time in our first season in the premiership. It was at Hillsborough but we must have had 4 or 5000 there. It was like watching a year 11 pupil playing with a load of year 7s at playtime.
The other was Akinbye Akinfenwe (prob got name wrong) about 5yrs ago when Northampton came to the Reebok in the early league cup rounds and single handedly dismantled us.
I'd put money on those players remembering those performances that day, both akin to the famous Okocha performance at White Hart Lane.
Fuck me, think that's the longest post i've ever done.