masi 51

No every body was right ...........Awful signing when Blackpool took Ennis at the same time

Alarm bells should have sounded when he slaughtered Crellin in his first season.....Yes he was awful but he should have just been taken out the team at the time and nobody would be any the wiser

Agreed should have swapped with Morley who ran Wycombe first half of the season playing in front of a back four

A player could not pay his council tax

Trump that in my opinion when Reading stepped up for that penalty at Wembley

Sorry had you mixed up with krimzon, though i do agree with your thoughts

1 Agree and Schumacher will get it right 2 He never just called out Sheehan but also our forwards stating they also cost us at Blackpool He also takes out players who he thinks are not cutting it,....IE Murphy who he could see was struggling some games. And like a good manager he is never went public because A he is not our player but more importantly he is young and nothing would be gained by lambasting him. 3 Great touch by the the Rotherham manager.....As for taking Reading place i hope it does not come down to that

Fuckin hell i actually agree on something you have posted

You are about as opposite as i am on our thoughts but i can respect them because they are what you believe We battered them yes and on other days we win that game.......It is not about last night, it is about every match since Wembley. You say the core is there but is it .And as for having 11 Thomasons over 11 Collins maybe that is why we are where we are......We need a mixture of them both. Collins is the only player who has you off your seat but you certainly dont want 11 of them. Let us look at the facts this season.......Baxter was shocking under Evatt with his distribution and along with Santos and Sheehan we give some stupid goals away, but i do not blame any of those three they are playing to a Managers instructions. Baxter since his return has been good. The defence next has conceded more goals than the top Dozen....Midfield next we have Morley and Sheehan playing in the wrong position.... Morley is streets ahead the best player in the team and he should be in the front of a back 4 dictating the game.......When did Sheehan last run a game??? Thomason, Matete, Lolos, Schon. Tutu, Randal....And Sheehan inconsistent . Dempsey Quality when fit. Forwards Mcatee getting better, Collins moments of genius but can go missing.....Victor, Nlundulu simply not good enough The three loan signings are not good enough, so on that i think it will be a re-build this summer

He has been brilliant but it is the system and nothing else that i have my reservations.....We are going nowhere playing with wingbacks It is outdated now and any good coach knows how to play against it...........Would i have Cogley in a right back role perhaps but that would stifle him, it is not Cogley it is plainly the system

Whatever System Schumacher goes with and i hope it to be a back four we need minimum 4 centre backs Three of Firino, Forrester and Toal would be a great platform to build a defence

As long as we keep employing this System we will limp along...It has not changed on the transition of Schumacher over Evatt. We simply do not have the personal to change it. Now i am going to say something very controversial here but it is a forum and they are my thoughts.....most will not agree with them. In the summer we need a mass clear out and that would include three players who have been excellent .....Johnston would be one who has been mentioned he would not get in the team next season as a centre back and not the answer as a left back. The next two may have many scratching their heads. Thomason is a enigma to me he puts in a great shift every game but everything is rushed and his end product is not the best. If we got good money for him he can go for me.......The last is the most controversial of the lot as he in my opinion is Quality and may have been mom for us tonight Cogley he is everything Evatt ball is about. He earned the contract extension and tonight he had our two best chances and there is the problem.....He is a defender and with the system of wingbacks he simply is not a goal scorer. Whatever Schumacher does in the summer it only then will be his team and only then will he be judged Toal, Firino, Forrester, Morley, Sheehan and Collins are the only ones i would not move on unless tempted with silly money

I have a feeling Schumacher does not fully trust Thomason in the centre of midfield. Not a clue on tonights line up be these lot will be direct... Can see hopefully a change in formation to a back 4 with Dempsey starting in midfield instead of Thomason who if he went to left back it would not surprise me. Great cross by geth Saturday but for me is now a bit part player

We either go 4/4/2 or we do not get to the play-offs period A midfield of Thomason, Sheehan Morley and Dempsey will get us there........The 3 at the back stiffles us we are shit playing this way....Great win today with the only bit of quality we are turgid

Get Toal, Dempsey and Morley in that starting eleven and we can start to believe