Tell me one player who has tried to end a players career like this ???

 

Victor has not played since.....and this was nearly 2 years ago FFS!!!!!

He's played umpteen times since.

 

And he scored against Birmingham in March.

I disagree on both.

 

Nolan was at it all game that day, and if you look back, pas his goals you will see, he has alwasy done it,.

 

Fellaini is just stupid, really thick. He jumps using his elbows, just like Kevin Davies does.....but he is much taller, so people come off worse.

 

How ANYONE can excuse that tackle above, I will never know.

im not excusing the tackle at all.

There is jumping with your elbows raised for elevation and then theres swinging them to intentionally hurt someone.

I disagree on both.

 

Nolan was at it all game that day, and if you look back, pas his goals you will see, he has alwasy done it,.

 

Fellaini is just stupid, really thick. He jumps using his elbows, just like Kevin Davies does.....but he is much taller, so people come off worse.

 

How ANYONE can excuse that tackle above, I will never know.

 

Moyes excused it

 

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/football/competitions/premier-league/4742292/David-Moyes-backs-Kevin-Nolan-after-horror-tackle.html

He's played umpteen times since.

 

And he scored against Birmingham in March.

 

He is still having further surgery from that incident. He has not been right since.

 

That tackle did his leg, anckle AND knee !

 

It ws shocking......and he didnt even get sent off !

 

 

EDIT : My mistake, he did get a red.

Edited November 1, 201015 yr by Pablo

Moyes excused it

 

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/football/competitions/premier-league/4742292/David-Moyes-backs-Kevin-Nolan-after-horror-tackle.html

 

 

I don't care. I dont follow what the Manager of my Club says in everything. Im able to form my own views, I am not a sheep!

 

That tack is WORSE than any of the bad one's this season by De Jong AND Henry !

im not excusing the tackle at all.

There is jumping with your elbows raised for elevation and then theres swinging them to intentionally hurt someone.

 

 

So now your excusing Davies too ??

 

Davies does just as bad as Fellaini !!

So now your excusing Davies too ??

 

Davies does just as bad as Fellaini !!

 

laughable.

He is still having further surgery from that incident. He has not been right since.

 

That tackle did his leg, anckle AND knee !

But he's played 11 times since?

 

You need a new medical team.

 

Unless you're talking shite.

I don't care. I dont follow what the Manager of my Club says in everything. Im able to form my own views, I am not a sheep!

 

That tack is WORSE than any of the bad one's this season by De Jong AND Henry !

 

I'm not following anyone

 

You said you don't know how ANYONE can excuse the tackle

 

i'm telling you your manager did.

But he's played 11 times since?

 

You need a new medical team.

 

Unless you're talking shite.

 

 

 

 

Pablo in talking shite shocker, surely not?

But he's played 11 times since?

 

You need a new medical team.

 

Unless you're talking shite.

 

in 2 years !!!!

 

That injury has fcuked Victor's career up. He is still suffering !

laughable.

 

 

Lets check out Yellow cards in the last 2 years then ??

 

Anyone ??

Lets check out Yellow cards in the last 2 years then ??

 

Anyone ??

Since Fellaini signed for Everton he's been booked 23 times.

 

Davies has been booked 19 times in the same period.

 

And played more games.

 

You're on fire today, though, keep it up.

Since Fellaini signed for Everton he's been booked 23 times.

 

Davies has been booked 19 times in the same period.

 

And played more games.

 

You're on fire today, though, keep it up.

 

 

I dont beleive that, can you send the proof ??

a scouser in denial

sure your not a liverpool fan pablo

i remember that tackle

 

nolan saw that cnut anichebe coming in over the ball and dealt with it

 

self defence

Pabbers, your arguments became void after claiming your man hadn't played in two years following that tackle.

 

Players are human, they make mistakes occasionally. Your man with the hair, however, seems to make his filthy gamesmanship a large part of his game. Live with it.

Fellaini is dirty, as is Davies.

 

BUT, Nolan is a cowardly twat, and I hope he get's done very soon. Cunt of a footballer.

Dirty yes.

 

An elbow to END A PLAYERS CAREER ???

 

Im still waiting for ANYTHNG even half as bad as that Nolan Tackle.

 

the face is a very fragile part of the body, if you go for someone with an elbow, there's no telling how how it will end up

 

http://www.soccerphile.com/soccerphile/premier-league/iain-hume.html

 

"On November 8, in a Championship game between Barnsley and Sheffield United, Tykes forward Iain Hume was on the end of a challenge by Blades Chris Morgan that left him with a fractured skull. An injury so serious that Hume received emergency brain surgery"

 

"In 1992, Torquay United's John Uzzell had his career ended, after being elbowed in the face by Brentford's Gary Blissett. Uzzell required reconstructive surgery and was almost blinded by this incident."

 

"Tottenham skipper Gary Mabbutt had his cheek bone shattered and an eye socket splintered in three sections following an elbow from John Fashunu."

 

"Nicky Summerbee was another victim of the elbow in 2000, when the then Wimbledon defender Ben Thatcher caught him in the face. Despite receiving a red card, Thatcher was banned for just two matches for the offence. He obviously didn't learn his lesson, as in 2006 he drove his elbow into Pedro Mendes' head during a Premiership match between Manchester City and Portsmouth. Mendes was left unconscious, requiring oxygen at pitch side having suffered a seizure. This just three weeks after Thatcher had elbowed a player in the chest, during a pre-season 'friendly'. His victim, Yang Chungang of Shanghai Shenhua, sustained a career-threatening collapsed lung as a result."

 

but as it says

 

violent intent could not be proven but if you throw enough shit at a wall, some sticks

 

http://www.google.co.uk/search?q=fellaini+elbow&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:en-GB:official&client=firefox-a

 

"The footage is clear, Fellaini elbows Hull's Michael Turner not once but twice"

 

"Marouane Fellaini ... was booked for using his elbow to jump in a challenge with James Perce on Saturday afternoon"

 

"Against Aston Villa on Sunday Fellaini's elbow connected with Curtis Davies and Zat Knight without proper punishment"

 

"Marouane Fellaini has revealed how a secret meeting between some of football?s most influential bosses helped him to change his ?dangerous? way"

Just like Ferguson was.

the face is a very fragile part of the body, if you go for someone with an elbow, there's no telling how how it will end up

 

http://www.soccerphile.com/soccerphile/premier-league/iain-hume.html

 

"On November 8, in a Championship game between Barnsley and Sheffield United, Tykes forward Iain Hume was on the end of a challenge by Blades Chris Morgan that left him with a fractured skull. An injury so serious that Hume received emergency brain surgery"

 

"In 1992, Torquay United's John Uzzell had his career ended, after being elbowed in the face by Brentford's Gary Blissett. Uzzell required reconstructive surgery and was almost blinded by this incident."

 

"Tottenham skipper Gary Mabbutt had his cheek bone shattered and an eye socket splintered in three sections following an elbow from John Fashunu."

 

"Nicky Summerbee was another victim of the elbow in 2000, when the then Wimbledon defender Ben Thatcher caught him in the face. Despite receiving a red card, Thatcher was banned for just two matches for the offence. He obviously didn't learn his lesson, as in 2006 he drove his elbow into Pedro Mendes' head during a Premiership match between Manchester City and Portsmouth. Mendes was left unconscious, requiring oxygen at pitch side having suffered a seizure. This just three weeks after Thatcher had elbowed a player in the chest, during a pre-season 'friendly'. His victim, Yang Chungang of Shanghai Shenhua, sustained a career-threatening collapsed lung as a result."

 

but as it says

 

violent intent could not be proven but if you throw enough shit at a wall, some sticks

 

http://www.google.co.uk/search?q=fellaini+elbow&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:en-GB:official&client=firefox-a

 

"The footage is clear, Fellaini elbows Hull's Michael Turner not once but twice"

 

"Marouane Fellaini ... was booked for using his elbow to jump in a challenge with James Perce on Saturday afternoon"

 

"Against Aston Villa on Sunday Fellaini's elbow connected with Curtis Davies and Zat Knight without proper punishment"

 

"Marouane Fellaini has revealed how a secret meeting between some of football?s most influential bosses helped him to change his ?dangerous? way"

 

 

Eye, very dirty. But still not career ending.

 

No mater how many Fellani links, Ferguson links.

 

 

Huge difference between what Fellain and Kevin Davies does, to what Nolan does and De Jong does.

 

If you dont see that then your an idiot.

Nolan's tackle on Anichebe was a yellow card at most.

Nolan was never the same player once Allardyce left. Both Sammy Lee and Megson ruined him.

Nolan was never the same player once Allardyce left. Both Sammy Lee and Megson ruined him.

 

He was never the same player when Okocha left. He became our creative midfield man aswell as our midfield goal scorer. Was too much for him. Noaln was always good at scoring 'box' goals.

Eye, very dirty. But still not career ending.

 

No mater how many Fellani links, Ferguson links.

 

Huge difference between what Fellain and Kevin Davies does, to what Nolan does and De Jong does.

 

If you dont see that then your an idiot.

 

Fellaini is constant offender with the elbow, even by his own admission with that "less dangerous" quote

 

fact is, despite his practice, I doubt he's accurate enough to know whether an elbow would end up being a career threatener or not, particulary if he leads with it

 

he does it alot and it could quite easily end up like an injury described in those links

 

just because he hasn't ended anyone's career when doing it, doesn't mean it's no better or worse than a two footed challenege, which also may or may not end a career

 

and I think it's fair to say Fellaini does more elbows than Nolan does two footed over the ball tackles, though I don't have anything to back that up

 

No mater how many Fellani links, Ferguson links.

 

aplogies for using some facts in my arguement, I know it's not your style