Is our current crop of defenders

 

Steinson / Cahill / A O'Brien / Samuel

 

Better than the likes of

 

Bergsson / Fish / Todd / Elliot

 

Bergsson / N'gotty / Laville / Mendy

 

Gardner/ N'gotty / Thome / Hunt

 

To perm but a few choices.

 

I'd say it is, individually they may not be & we had a few players past there pomp but still very good.

 

What do you think?.

Is our current crop of defenders

 

Steinson / Cahill / A O'Brien / Samuel

 

Better than the likes of

 

Bergsson / Fish / Todd / Elliot

 

Bergsson / N'gotty / Laville / Mendy

 

Gardner/ N'gotty / Thome / Hunt

 

To perm but a few choices.

 

I'd say it is, individually they may not be & we had a few players past there pomp but still very good.

 

What do you think?.

Bergsson / N'gotty / Laville / Steinson for me

I would go for

Steinsson/ Bergsson/ Bruno/ Charlton

What? You've possibly the finest centre half ever to pull on a White shirt.

 

Shame on you, think again.

 

He cost a quid...

What? You've possibly the finest centre half ever to pull on a White shirt.

 

Shame on you, think again.

 

He cost a quid...

 

ben haim???

I would go for

Steinsson/ Bergsson/ Bruno/ Charlton

 

oh my lord

 

 

ben haim, bergsson, ngotty, gardner

What? You've possibly the finest centre half ever to pull on a White shirt.

 

Shame on you, think again.

 

He cost a quid...

Hierro?

Diawara, Seagraves, Cesar, Cid

Bergsson / N'gotty / Laville / Steinson for me

 

Who's playing left back?

Who's playing left back?

 

Be bruno wont it

Ben haim FFS he should not get a mention.

 

we have had some good uns in my time, Bergson for me was no1.

N'Gotty / Bergsson / Cahill / Gardner

Who's playing left back?

 

I always thought Candela was a good player. Best right footed left back we've had at least.

N'gotty - Gudni - Cahill - Gardner

N'gotty - Gudni - Cahill - Gardner

 

Great minds n all that.

Hunt-Ben Haim-Bergsson-Gardner

McAnespie - Hunt - Fairclough - Henrik

Great minds n all that.

 

 

Hard to argue with that

 

I mean your back four by the way, not the great minds bit

deakin-valentine-sutton-scott.

 

i think there the best back 4 we've ever had.

An all time back four has to have baza at left back!

barry barry barry

deakin-valentine-sutton-scott.

 

i think there the best back 4 we've ever had.

 

 

Not even close

barness / bergsson / whitlow / charlton

 

great job by them lads

deakin-valentine-sutton-scott.

 

i think there the best back 4 we've ever had.

I'm sure the topic title states in the 'Prem'

Are there two threads in one here? I thought the question was about the best back four who played together, in which case I would say that the current 4 are as good as we have seen in the Prem...

 

...but some posts seem to be listing a fantasy line up of our best 4 defenders.

listing a fantasy line up of our best 4 defenders.

 

Reet then, that's different.

 

Banks - Hulme - Allardyce - Hartle.