Don't make this into another 'Smegson is a tosser' thread.

It would be interesting if fans just thought about how good of a manager Megson really is in their view, taking into account motivating players , tactics, players he wants in etc. and simply give him a score of how you rate him out of 100. Also take into account what potential he has of moving us forward and shaping a team in the future, not just past results.

In 2 years time when we are in a Uefa Cup position just before christmas 2010 we can look back at this page to see how many points we gave him, and give a new score.

 

Be as honest as you can and keep comments down to a minimum.

Anyone who puts 0 or 100 can be classed as not putting a serious answer.

I will start

 

66/100

45

 

and i am one of the ones who would give him till end of season

37

Premiership 15

8/30. Enough said.

25 and Im feeling generous

Why out of 100?

Why out of 100?

looks like that's the rule of the originator.

 

Any thoughts to improve?

26/100 if he wasnt ginger it would be 30/100

40/100

 

Seems like a long time ago since we played well

 

at home, must be down to Megson tactics needs to start

 

attacking now from the word go or we fcuked,if Riga

 

does not start in morn he has to go.

i,m going to give him 20/100, only because of the signings he as made, i think they have been good signings, his tactics are negative, blah,blah,blah.

 

p.s

and as for megson keeping up last season, i still think it was because of the fans getting behind the team in the last few games

and the players getting motivated by it.

Edited November 1, 200817 yr by STAN

In the Prem : 15/100

Decent signings, but no midfield.

Motivation low.

Tactics low.

Best use of players low.

Substitutions largely laughable.

Football dire.

And, yes, I'm being serious.

50/100, Just think -just 12 months ago fans were chanting "Ginger Mourinho" in the Allianz Arena after drawing 2-2 with the mighty Bayern Munich. He kept us up against all odds last season, and on the whole his signings have been decent.

Edited November 1, 200817 yr by Burndens Bogs

58/100

58/100

 

Premiership 25/100

 

Championship 70/100

Signings 7/10

Players he wants in 5/10

Motivation 1/10

Tactical nous 1/10

Performances 1/10

Stability 6/10

Quality of football 1/10

Use of Players 3/10

Overall results 4/10

Beating United 1-0, drawing 2-2 with B.Munich 9/10

38/100

40/100

 

Good solid signings - though if Muamba, Elmander and Taylor don't come good soon that aspect will suffer. Could be argued he's not bought what we actually need - creativity / pace.

 

Stable team selections, patience with players - a good thing

 

We are quite tight defensively

 

Speaks common sense generally and HAS had some bad luck

 

BUT

 

Negative selections especially at home

 

Negative tactics and formations, again especially in the vital home games

 

Baffling (non-)use of substitutes, appears to be overly cautious

 

 

 

Overall his record in the premiership speaks for itself. Doesn't seem to have what it takes. He's had plenty of games and his win record is abysmal.

My rating is 6/ 100

His signings have been no better than the ones allowed to leave simple as. As one example, Matt Taylor, no better than what we already had. Megson has to go.

 

Beer swiller

30/100. A Championship standard manager.

If 1 = Les Reed

 

and

 

100 = Fergie

 

Then i'll give him 20/100.

Id say bout 50/100,his signings were good and i still think Elmander will come good,also for some reason whenever we get a result i think we can really push on but we never do!

 

On a different note is Zozzy Megsons love child,cause he sure does have a place in his heart for him!

33/100

23.4456

58008

5 0 blind 50.