27 minutes ago, Johnnyrotten said:

That just leaves Santos and Jones as the outfield players who play every game they are fit. 

Johnston as well surely, what with him being the best defender we actually have?

 

 

7 hours ago, JimmyRiddle said:

Yet never been left out?? How can some of those on the bench not be thinking double standards at play by Evatt

We havent got a direct replacement for him

Theres none outside the prem

Top drawer today

Our strongest line up going forward imo

Trafford

Jones, Santos, Iredale

Bradley, MJ, Lee, Morley, Beck

Charles, Dapo/Bodvarsson

 

Dapo for me is better out left wing rather than left forward, but we'd have to change our entire system to accommodate that 

3 hours ago, Zico said:

What did he say? 

I wasn't sure about that midfield but they played very well and after some mistakes recently thought Santos was very good 

Most surprising was John on the bench, thought he was out for some time with us signing Beck, thought he might come on for Iredale who looked knackered second half

Don't rate Baka as a starter so the sooner JDB is back the better 

Few twitchy arses when Trafford went down with no sub keeper

Guessing Sadlier didn't take his chance the other night

Bizarre, you said

8 minutes ago, Lostock Whites said:

Our strongest line up going forward imo

Trafford

Jones, Santos, Iredale

Bradley, MJ, Lee, Morley, Beck

Charles, Dapo/Bodvarsson

 

Dapo for me is better out left wing rather than left forward, but we'd have to change our entire system to accommodate that 

How can you pick Beck as first choice when you haven’t seen him play?

6 minutes ago, desperado said:

Could you imagine the outrage tonight if we had lost and Sadlier hadn’t made it onto the pitch?

It just goes to show no matter how much we pontificate we really don’t know how these players have performed in training and impressed Evatt to make the starting 11.

There’s no way I would have predicted a starting 11 without Dempsey or Morley today, never mind both of them.

Sometimes we just have to trust Evatt that he knows what he is doing.

(I did say that after Tuesday Thomason was closer to the starting 11 than Sadlier 😉)

Yes you called that one, fair play!  Although I think I'm closer to a starting place than Sadlier (captain of Park Lee primary 1977, with a deceptive lack of pace).

Playing devils's advocate, but a 3-1 win, which could have been 5-1  or 2-2 (if our handball goal wasn't given?) doesn't always mean every selection is spot on.  Its just conjecture that if "X" player plays instead of "Y", we don't win.  I find it stretching it a bit to think we couldn't have beaten Charlton if any of Dempsey, Morley or Sadlier had started instead of Thomasson, Lee or Bradley (of the 3, I thought Bradley was often wasteful and his crossing very average today, as good as he can be).  If Sadlier had started and we won, some would be saying "see, I told you" and that doesn't make that any more valid than the opposite view.  We have a load of midfielders, whoever plays, we are decent with qualities and faults.  If we win, the one's that don't play are still good, if we lose, those that played aren't poor.  And being a bit puzzled as to why Sadlier is still miles behind everyone else for minutes still seems valid, for arguments sake if he'd come on for 20 minutes instead of either Dapo, Tomo or Bradley I don't think we would have been hugely weakened.

 

 

2 hours ago, Arrested development said:

Thomasson had a good game , so did Kieran Lee but their midfield was dire. Don't think kieron Lee got marked once all game. 

gonna be tougher games coming up , especially away from home but today was good 

So, how about you dont rip the selection to bits?

2 hours ago, Mounts Kipper said:

Fantastic Lee today, but I agree with you Lee is better player at home, often goes missing away and even at home against a powerful midfield can go absent,

Yawn

Yawn

Fucking yawn

27 minutes ago, ErnestTurnip said:

Johnston as well surely, what with him being the best defender we actually have?

I thought Johnstone got dropped once or twice last year?  I don't think Santos or Jones did, without checking.  And some think that Iredale might take his place for some games.  Definitely not the best defender today, beaten far too easily by their winger a number of times.

33 minutes ago, Lostock Whites said:

Think today really reinforced what I knew before, Baka isn't good enough, in his role with our style of play he needs to be touch and bang to our players around him when in transition and surrounded by multiple opposition. 

Today showed he can't do that, his touch, control and hold up play for a 6ft 4 striker is quite bad

Bodvarsson is a level above him.

I think last year showed us his role as a bench impact player.

If evatts choice is bod or baka, he only had one choice today

21 minutes ago, Casino said:

Bizarre, you said

It was 

Morley was as regular as the unchanged defense and Baka hasn't done much to warrant a start 

 

3 minutes ago, Zico said:

It was 

Morley was as regular as the unchanged defense and Baka hasn't done much to warrant a start 

 

Its only bizzare if you doubt evatt

Dunno why anybody would

He gets 9/10 right

32 minutes ago, Casino said:

Guessing Sadlier didn't take his chance the other night

He did. And I was perhaps his biggest critic.

The point I was trying to make, which has been backed up by todays performance, is that others staked their claim more- Thomason (even though I wasn’t expecting that selection and that kind of performance today)

The fact that we have someone like Sadlier on the bench should be viewed as a positive, not a negative. 

 

1 hour ago, Tonge moor green jacket said:

I've just read about this as I had no idea who/what the comment was about. Every day is a school day!

Pretty good limited series about DB Cooper on Netflix.

4 hours ago, Black Sheep said:

Very brave selection from IE, he would have got dogs abuse if we had lost today after making so many changes. Although I don't necessary agree with him making 4 or 5 changes every game, but today he got it spot on.

Thomason & Lee outstanding, Bakayoko not so (IMO) - I honestly can't see what he brings to the team, and I still think that we need to be stronger at the back, although Santos had a good game. 

Very good & important 3 points. 

Good points 👏

23 minutes ago, Johnnyrotten said:

Yes you called that one, fair play!  Although I think I'm closer to a starting place than Sadlier (captain of Park Lee primary 1977, with a deceptive lack of pace).

Playing devils's advocate, but a 3-1 win, which could have been 5-1  or 2-2 (if our handball goal wasn't given?) doesn't always mean every selection is spot on.  Its just conjecture that if "X" player plays instead of "Y", we don't win.  I find it stretching it a bit to think we couldn't have beaten Charlton if any of Dempsey, Morley or Sadlier had started instead of Thomasson, Lee or Bradley (of the 3, I thought Bradley was often wasteful and his crossing very average today, as good as he can be).  If Sadlier had started and we won, some would be saying "see, I told you" and that doesn't make that any more valid than the opposite view.  We have a load of midfielders, whoever plays, we are decent with qualities and faults.  If we win, the one's that don't play are still good, if we lose, those that played aren't poor.  And being a bit puzzled as to why Sadlier is still miles behind everyone else for minutes still seems valid, for arguments sake if he'd come on for 20 minutes instead of either Dapo, Tomo or Bradley I don't think we would have been hugely weakened.

 

 

Sadlier seems to be your new Darcy! 

Although I do think Sadlier has something to offer this team - but I’m happy for Evatt to decide if/when those circumstances arise.

I think if we had been chasing the game today, after the positive performance lots thought he had Tuesday, we might have seen him. 

But today Evatts selection and substitutions were spot on

 

23 minutes ago, Casino said:

Its only bizzare if you doubt evatt

Dunno why anybody would

He gets 9/10 right

Spot on.

Apologies above - wasn’t quoting you re Sadlier, don’t know why  it’s quoted as your comment

Think it was @Zicowho made the comment “Guessing Sadlier didn't take his chance the other night”

To which I replied:

He did. And I was perhaps his biggest critic.

The point I was trying to make, which has been backed up by todays performance, is that others staked their claim more- Thomason (even though I wasn’t expecting that selection and that kind of performance today)

The fact that we have someone like Sadlier on the bench should be viewed as a positive, not a negative. 

Edited September 3, 20223 yr by desperado

Cheers

I was just tracking down the quoted post

Didnt feel like one of mine.

from what i saw today, some cracking stuff. First half was all about bradley and george, but we really should have more efforts on goal

Good performance.

traff made some vital saves.

baka only under par player.

Iredale, Bradley, Thomason had good games.

need to back up with another win next week tho.

Once again a highlights show which doesn’t consider a legitimate goal ruled offside incorrectly a highlight or at least a discussion point.

We all know the excitement occurs at the goal-scoring end but Trafford made some great saves and only one gets shown. 

5 minutes ago, MickyD said:

Once again a highlights show which doesn’t consider a legitimate goal ruled offside incorrectly a highlight or at least a discussion point.

Good job we can discuss on here then 😊

It would (and should) have been the cherry on the top of his performance today.  

I think, as @Ani pointed out, there was a flick on from one of our players a split second after that and Thomason was stood in an offside position.

10 minutes ago, Lt. Aldo Raine said:

I think, as @Ani pointed out, there was a flick on from one of our players a split second after that and Thomason was stood in an offside position.

Aye. Looked like Charles got a touch on it to me.

Edit: Although I've just watched this, and am no longer convinced.

 

Edited September 3, 20223 yr by Cheese

1 hour ago, ErnestTurnip said:

Johnston as well surely, what with him being the best defender we actually have?

Just as an aside, I thought Johnston was sub-par for a lot of today. Bit of a wobble after a largely strong start to the season.

Good win against a team the fans expect to finish lower than us.

16 minutes ago, Cheese said:

Aye. Looked like Charles got a touch on it to me.

Edit: Although I've just watched this, and am no longer convinced.

 

Not sure if it’s Charles but I think it’s flicked on here, by which point GT’s beyond the last defender.

Shame really as it would’ve topped off a great performance from him.