Jump to content
Wanderers Ways. Neil Thompson 1961-2021

Recommended Posts

Posted

He’s had about a handful good 20 minute spells in a year and a half. 

He might be physically big but he barely ever dominates defenders and I’ve never seen him win a flick on or cushion a ball down to another player

If we are going long in the last 10 he’s the last thing we need to be booting it to. Better off sticking a centre back up there.

Snatch hands off for a million or anywhere close to that if it balances the books.

Revert back to 3 in midfield and 2 up top.

Charles, Collins and McAtee to cover the 3 with CMG back in a few months. 
 

4 players for 2 is more than enough. 
 

Can get a loan in in January if we get a few injuries.

Posted
5 minutes ago, Eavesy said:

He’s had about a handful good 20 minute spells in a year and a half. 

He might be physically big but he barely ever dominates defenders and I’ve never seen him win a flick on or cushion a ball down to another player

If we are going long in the last 10 he’s the last thing we need to be booting it to. Better off sticking a centre back up there.

Snatch hands off for a million or anywhere close to that if it balances the books.

Revert back to 3 in midfield and 2 up top.

Charles, Collins and McAtee to cover the 3 with CMG back in a few months. 
 

4 players for 2 is more than enough. 
 

Can get a loan in in January if we get a few injuries.

What if Charles and one of the others gets injured like last season?

Posted
5 minutes ago, gonzo said:

What if Charles and one of the others gets injured like last season?

We can just change formation. We had loads of injuries last season, probably won't have any this year.

£1m is good money for him, but I am convinced he might still come good. 

Posted

Is Vic supposed to be a goalscorer or merely a forward type player? If the former how many goals has he scored in the last 12 months and apply simple maths to work the cost goal if we sell for 1mill. Therefore IMO time to cash in.

Posted
1 hour ago, Marc505 said:

Always wary of ITK accounts with only a dozen followers, but one is suggesting we're in talks with Spurs over Alfie Devine on loan

Sure we've been linked with him every window since he was born

Posted
35 minutes ago, Ani said:

We can just change formation. We had loads of injuries last season, probably won't have any this year.

£1m is good money for him, but I am convinced he might still come good. 

Aye our manager is well know for adapting and changing systems to suit missing personnel.

Especially when players tire during games :)

Posted
1 hour ago, Eavesy said:

He’s had about a handful good 20 minute spells in a year and a half. 

He might be physically big but he barely ever dominates defenders and I’ve never seen him win a flick on or cushion a ball down to another player

If we are going long in the last 10 he’s the last thing we need to be booting it to. Better off sticking a centre back up there.

Snatch hands off for a million or anywhere close to that if it balances the books.

Revert back to 3 in midfield and 2 up top.

Charles, Collins and McAtee to cover the 3 with CMG back in a few months. 
 

4 players for 2 is more than enough. 
 

Can get a loan in in January if we get a few injuries.

This is where I’m at. If he’s not the long term answer and we have short term options until January, I’d let him go.

We’ve already got people saying we can’t fit McAtee, Collins and Charles into the line up. When Lolos and CMG are back, the problem is intensified. If we have a major injury issue, there is still Dan (who I believe is also due to come good soon… 🙃)

Posted
1 hour ago, gonzo said:

I'm saying £1m is useless to us now and having Vic till at least Jan is worth every penny.

Unless there's another coming the door in the space of a few hours.

There's also free agents that don't have to sign today.

  • Moderators
Posted
2 hours ago, Lancaster18 said:

Didn’t we pay around 1m for mcatee?
Levels above vic.. can’t believe we haven’t accepted it unless with add ons it totals 1m.

Depends on how you value a player I guess 

McAtee has one season in L1 under his belt 

Vic has five and 2 in the championship 

Posted
5 minutes ago, Zico said:

Depends on how you value a player I guess 

McAtee has one season in L1 under his belt 

Vic has five and 2 in the championship 

And we were absolutely flying with him and Charles up top last season.

Posted
30 minutes ago, Zico said:

Depends on how you value a player I guess 

McAtee has one season in L1 under his belt 

Vic has five and 2 in the championship 

Since 2020/21 season

He scored 5 goals in 60 champ games..

25 goals in 85 league one appearances.

Can’t assist or hold the ball up.

If we go up we’d want to move him on anyway. For me find a decent prem loan easier said than done i know. Or like someone said Gayle is a free agent and proven scorer for a season.

 

Posted
Just now, Lancaster18 said:

Since 2020/21 season

He scored 5 goals in 60 champ games..

25 goals in 85 league one appearances.

Can’t assist or hold the ball up.

If we go up we’d want to move him on anyway. For me find a decent prem loan easier said than done i know. Or like someone said Gayle is a free agent and proven scorer for a season.

 

He holds the ball up fine

Posted
34 minutes ago, nantwichwhite said:

To be fair he does, he's improved no end this season

Was watching him last season Could tell he was learning how to shield ball and hold it up from/like CJ. He started backing in and position himself in nearly an identical way.

  • Site Supporter
Posted

If a team the league above value him at 1m, and that's based on detailed analysis from scouts, I daresay there's probably more understanding than you're average fan. 

More to the point Evatt feels it's not enough which means Evatt values him higher than Mcatee.. (if I'm right in thinking we payed 1m for him). 

  • Moderators
Posted
2 hours ago, Lancaster18 said:

Since 2020/21 season

He scored 5 goals in 60 champ games..

25 goals in 85 league one appearances.

Can’t assist or hold the ball up.

If we go up we’d want to move him on anyway. For me find a decent prem loan easier said than done i know. Or like someone said Gayle is a free agent and proven scorer for a season.

 

I guess they'd have to offer more than we value him at 

He's part of our plan, the plan is promotion  

Losing him weakens us, would need a ready made replacement of equal of better standard 

On deadline day 

I'm happy for him to stay

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.