Got to go for me 7 months of hardly any improvement.Out of his depth

We can't carry on like this

Edited January 24, 20215 yr by Casino

Rufus?

I'm usually in the give them time camp but I can't see where we are going under Evatt now. I just think some simple, pragmatic decisions could make a lot of difference but our manager can't. Chino got more shit for competing with a worse squad in a higher league at one of the worst points in our history. 

Doubts are starting to creep in for me. Arthur simply has to start the next game.

No improvement going nowhere this

if FV want bums on seats next season they need a think 

In

In

Doesn't really matter who the manager is at this basket case but i think the decision to sack Hill and replace with Evatt weakened the club

I just don't know . I would say give him more time because we aren't going down and we certainly don't look like going up anytime soon .BUT  the performances just keep regressing and I can't see hardly any green shoots that it is all going to fall in place anytime soon.

Mansfield made a decision early , got in Clough and haven't looked back . Personally though I'm weary of constant change , but we have to start turning a corner soon .

 

I'd say in , for a bit longer.

 

 

Edited January 23, 20215 yr by dusan nikolic

In for now. Players are letting him down, big time.

Before I answer, has Pulis found a club yet?

I say in 

Out!!

In until the end of the season.

No sign of improvement by then...

Out

In - you don't pay for a new man to come in and sack him in the same season. Especially under the circumstances we're currently in.

I don't think there's a single one of us that isn't bitterly disappointed with how we've performed so far. He gets the rest of this season and the start of the next for me. Barring any absolute catastrophe.

The frustrating thing is - I still can't think of many games where we've been outplayed. 

Needs a win soon .

Mansfield will be a test , not sure the players are giving their all .

Shite performance again will see him gone I reckon.

In for now but ice is getting thinner.

Out. No discernable plan, players not motivated and no improvement or even a prospect of it in my eyes. I fear the guy is an over confident fraud unfortunately 

in until the summer

Can he sign this head turning front man ???

Will he sign a keeper ????

I am giving him the benefit of the doubt until i see who he releases

Not saying for one minute we will get relegated but 7 points off drop zone and a few clubs have one & two games in hand 

In 

Gets to start next season for me

The players are clearly not motivated and don’t seem to care until they go a goal or two down.

That’s down to IE.

For professional footballers they are collectively languid.

Covid is saving his job, because there would be far more pressure if fans were in the ground.

For me he goes which is a shame as he talked a good game when he came,  but talk is cheap.

13 minutes ago, kent_white said:

In - you don't pay for a new man to come in and sack him in the same season. Especially under the circumstances we're currently in.

Why don't you, he clearly isn't delivering what he promised the board? 

He has shown nothing to me that he will be successful, he has not got a track record to give us confidence with, he is a rookie manager.

So if we are going to pot him, pot him now, if we give him in another year or two, and we are still if this division!! it will have compounded a poor decision to give the guy a job in the first place.

If Salford or Mansfield go up and we don't, they will have been brave, and we will have been weak. A gamble yes, but you are not telling me a proper manager couldn't get some kind of tune from those players. 

It's all about opinions but I am genuinely at a loss as to what people think are positives from the guy, what is it that gives you a glimmer of hope, we are bottom half of the 4th divison???

Edited January 23, 20215 yr by JimmyRiddle

When he was first appointed I was well up for it thinking we've got a good one here at last.But his stubbornness ( in playing possession football when in this league it's more about graft,hard work,getting the ball in the box)is mind boggling. I don't see improvement all I see is shite defending,a weak midfield and frustrated forwards 

I hope he proves me wrong but enough is enough 

3 minutes ago, JimmyRiddle said:

Why don't you, he clearly isn't delivering what he promised the board? 

He has shown nothing to me that he will be successful, he has not got a track record to give us confidence with, he is a rookie manager.

So if we are going to pot him, pot him now, if we give him in another year or two, and we are still if this division!! it will have compounded a poor decision to give the guy a job in the first place.

If Salford or Mansfield go up and we don't, they will have been brave, and we will have been weak. A gamble yes, but you are not telling me a proper manager couldn't get some kind of tune from those players. 

It's all about opinions but I am genuinely at a loss as to what people think are positives from the guy, what is it that gives you a glimmer of hope, we are bottom half of the 4th divison???

That's one way of looking at it. And I respect your opinion. You might well be right. I just tend to err on the side of giving managers time - unless they're absolutely having a calamity or take a team down or do something unforgivable. 

In....

 

10 minutes ago, kent_white said:

In - you don't pay for a new man to come in and sack him in the same season. Especially under the circumstances we're currently in.

I don't think there's a single one of us that isn't bitterly disappointed with how we've performed so far. He gets the rest of this season and the start of the next for me. Barring any absolute catastrophe.

The frustrating thing is - I still can't think of many games where we've been outplayed. 

But 2nd best in the vast majority of games in this poor league, not good enough surely.  

I don't know the financial implications of a change of manager so I'm not answering it without having the facts to hand, and without knowing who the alternative might be, I just know that IE is a big disappointment and I don't believe his bluster any more.