Transfer Gossip

[tomski]

6 hours ago, mickbrown said:

He’s worse 

Each to their own and all that. I think he could be an asset. Some of the dross we have seen in the last 15 years and a lad that scored 9/10 goals isn’t even close.

[Zico]

7 hours ago, Zog1 said:

Two others i remember us being linked to countless times were

Owen Hargreaves

Andrew Johnson

We only signed Anelka because we missed out on Johnson who went to Everton instead

[Blondi]

10 hours ago, Whitesince63 said:

How about Malik Wilkes released by Wednesday, he has all those qualities and can score a goal too?

Also, haven't Huddersfield released Josh Koroma? Think he's a left sided player, always thought he looked likely when I've seen him.

Edited June 10, 2025 by Blondi

[Wiso]

Back to Dalby, he looks like he could be useful. Shown potential and then stalled. A bit like Matheson, but without the injury worries - so hopefully works out better than that.

In terms of ability:

Can he trap a bag of cement? If so, better than our other forwards

Can he attack the ball instead of randomly barging into the player? If so, better than McAtee

Does he have feet and a head that he can use? Better than our current forwards

[Zico]

41 minutes ago, Wiso said:

Back to Dalby, he looks like he could be useful. Shown potential and then stalled. A bit like Matheson, but without the injury worries - so hopefully works out better than that.

Dalby is way ahead of Mattheson ever was in terms of games and development

he's 25 and in the last 4 years played 151 games and scored 31 goals

he's ready, not raw and untested

[Only In Welsh]

Going by some comments on here we dodged a bullet by missing out on signing McAtee to you. I know he came to us for talks and was shown around, and that we both offered exactly the same contract, so it was a straight choice for him. That came from our Humphry Kerr who is a director.  I'll be honest I barely noticed he was on the pitch when we played you and he didn't impress. 

He smashed us when he played for Grimsby mind.

 

[Blondi]

Xavier Simmons defensive midfielder now being linked from Hull.

[L/H White]

Peps just done his best bit of business by getting Klopps right hand man as his assistant 

[Wiso]

28 minutes ago, Blondi said:

Xavier Simmons defensive midfielder now being linked from Hull.

Presume he played alongside Morley first half of last season at Wycombe. On that basis, looks a good move

 

[Wiso]

41 minutes ago, Zico said:

Dalby is way ahead of Mattheson ever was in terms of games and development

he's 25 and in the last 4 years played 151 games and scored 31 goals

he's ready, not raw and untested

Yeah, wasn't making the direct comparison - just the fact that he made a big move early, and has had to build back from that. Matheson was unable to due to injury

[Johnnyrotten]

1 hour ago, Wiso said:

Can he trap a bag of cement? If so, better than our other forwards

Can he attack the ball instead of randomly barging into the player? If so, better than McAtee

Does he have feet and a head that he can use? Better than our current forwards

Agreed on the attacking the ball instead of the player bit, but a bit harsh re the feet. 

There is every chance Dalby won't be as good as Collins especially with his feet, very unlikely to be as creative, and I guarantee he won't be as comfortable taking the ball on his left foot, Collins is one of very few 2 footed players that I've seen in this league.

But that's not why SS has signed a 6 foot 3 player who can head a ball with purpose and direction.

[Whitesince63]

23 minutes ago, Wiso said:

Presume he played alongside Morley first half of last season at Wycombe. On that basis, looks a good move

 

Don’t think he did, I believe he was signed as the replacement for Morley when he came back here.

[Johnnyrotten]

54 minutes ago, Only In Welsh said:

Going by some comments on here we dodged a bullet by missing out on signing McAtee to you. I know he came to us for talks and was shown around, and that we both offered exactly the same contract, so it was a straight choice for him. That came from our Humphry Kerr who is a director.  I'll be honest I barely noticed he was on the pitch when we played you and he didn't impress. 

He smashed us when he played for Grimsby mind.

 

Can't disagree with that, I don't see how Parky possibly fits McAtee into his style of play (ie a striker that can't head a ball), so its a mystery why he was after him in the first place.  I thought we were getting a centre forward type when he signed but whatever he is he isn't that.  But we've had far worse, he scored some good goals, has a positive attitude and is a good team player.

To be fair, in both our 0-0 games I'm not sure anyone stood out so I'll cut him some slack in those games, nobody was scoring or standing out in either of our 0-0 bore fests, those games were very L1. 

[gonzo]

Think a lot of stick comes McAtees way because of the piss poor way he carries himself. 

Socks rolled down, shirt out, blaming every fucker every time something goes wrong. 

He just looks like a Billy Big Bollocks. The type you see in Sunday teams, body checking folk and giving loads out.

Trouble is when you're like that, you've got to be able to back it up.

Do it and the fans will love you. But don't and you've had it.

You can be limited and still get on ok in this division as long as you put a shift in and look professional. 

I think with a bit of coaching and man management there could be a player in him.

Looks a nightmare to coach but he's the type where you earn your coin.

[L/H White]

Trafford to Newcastle

[Steejay]

What’s our sell-on amount?

[L/H White]

2 minutes ago, Steejay said:

What’s our sell-on amount?

pack of space raiders

[little whitt]

1 minute ago, Steejay said:

What’s our sell-on amount?

when he went to Burnley 

Carlisle got 2.5 million 

[Cheese]

2 minutes ago, Steejay said:

What’s our sell-on amount?

The profit from whatever he spends when he comes to watch us on his days off.

[Zico]

he was criticised on here for joining Burnley

seems to have worked out well for him

[nantwichwhite]

This Dalby geezer looks more like a Phillipskirk type. He did very well for us in this league.

[W.cramp]

32 minutes ago, L/H White said:

Trafford to Newcastle

Good on the lad.

[nantwichwhite]

 

[gonzo]

35 minutes ago, L/H White said:

pack of space raiders

Beef or pickled onion?

[L/H White]

1 minute ago, gonzo said:

Beef or pickled onion?

pickled onion always, unless the beef is halal 

Edited June 10, 2025 by L/H White