Jump to content
Wanderers Ways. Neil Thompson 1961-2021

Take Over


Kane57

Recommended Posts

7 hours ago, Farrelli said:

According to the local Stoke newspaper former Port Vale owner Norman Smurthwaite is looking at our situation as possible new owner. 

Asset stripper par excellence 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

32 minutes ago, Hoppy510 said:

Nixon implying that the decision underpinning buying now from Anderson v buying out of admin = saving £28 million v 12 point deduction.

Frankly I don't think this is the case or that the numbers are necessarily right, but if it was the case I'd rather take the deduction and hope the money was spent on putting together a team that would get promoted despite the deduction - and form the basis of a Championship contending side the following season.

 

Playoffs might be doable starting on -12, but we'd need to be aiming for over 100 points to go up automatically. Whatever team you'd have to build to make that likely would probably cost £10m+.

10m for 12 points guaranteed would be a smart investment, if you had the money.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

38 minutes ago, Clarence Carter said:

Would have to be some team to get promotion, we could be looking at a 20 point deduction.

If we started on minus 20 we would have to play like league winners and aim to finish 6th and go up by the play offs 

In the last 5 seasons including this season in League one the gap between champions and 6th place has been 21 , 27 , 27 , 13 & 30 points so its theoretically possible in most seasons   

Realistically - a  very tall order 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's all speculation, the lot of it, the investors, the points deductions. Something I have learn't over the last few months since joining here, is don't believe fuck all until it happens

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Sluffy said:

I'll have a punt at answering this but it really is very difficult to actually know what the answer is!.

First of all I assume you are talking about the £5m loaned to KA who then loaned it to the club, which then went on to pay the BluMarble loan with.

It seems by the time the loan was issued there must have been some doubt if Eddie would have got it back without securing the loan on something or other, as apparently he had loaned KA previously £3m (if what is H has been telling us is correct - and I've no reason to doubt him on that) as an unsecured loan.  I guess if the 'trust' was still there then this £5m would have been loaned as per the previous one/s?

The reason I have read that the loan was not secured against club assets directly was apparently and the clubs assets had been 'maxed' out, so it was secured instead against KA's assets

I thought originally that the loan was against the share ownership but looking more deeply into it I believe the loan was secured against the company that owned the share ownership namely Inner Circle Investments Limited.  And accordingly a charge for £5m was set against ICI Ltd. (on the 7th Sept, 2018)

https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/09782053/charges/fm5WZUnhZHCq-kA5LdXv1g9627M

Ken in turn some days later then presumably 'found' £5m from somewhere because he made himself a secured creditor of the club (presumably for the £5m) on the 27th Sept, 2018, BUT under his own name and not that of ICI Ltd!

https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/00043026/charges/zuFLo9CUMVpD9kLSumePBFGSR-g

Poor Eddie passed away on the 11th Sept, 2018 

And the BluMarble loan was reportedly settled on the 12th Sept, 2018 - presumably for circa £5m, being £4m capital plus around £800k interest(?).

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/45483786

However note the timeline for all these events

If BM was paid £5m on the 12th Sept, then where did the £5m KA loaned the club come from TWO WEEKS LATER?

Companies House clearly shows the BM loan being satisfied on the 24th September...

https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/03674979/charges/_53gxL4LeazNGlMRE9QxDhU0CgQ

...so where did his £5m come from to secure against the club 27th Sept?

I can only reason from all this that the £5m Eddie loaned KA to pay BM actually did happen and that the £5m Ken put in the club as a secured creditor was completely separate and apart from the Davies loan.

In short it really was from KA (although that may have been funded on advances on player sales and ST sales revenue, factored in advance?)

Are you still with me so far!

We've dealt I think with the monies going in, so what about the money being paid back?

I won't trouble you by repeating the lengthy and informative narrative Howard has previously given on this and just pick things up where H has informed us that putting the club into Admin does not invalidate the sum of £5m still being owed to Eddies estate. 

As it stands as far as I understand it, it basically means that if the default is called in by Moonshine they take control of ICI Ltd, who are the holding company for the club.

IF I've got this correct (and I certainly don't guarantee I have!) then I also believe that the conditions of the loan also prevent ICI Ltd going into voluntary Liquidation as H suggests it may well do so.  I say this on the basis of the charge saying - under 5.2 that disposal of security assets can't be made (and security assets being defined in the Definitions as all of the assets subject to the deed).  Therefore in my thinking anyway, if the deed is about taking control of ICI in default, then how can it dispose of itself first by voluntary liquidation?

https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/09782053/charges/fm5WZUnhZHCq-kA5LdXv1g9627M 

Of course I am very much out of my depth on these matters and would appreciate comments and or guidance from those who are more knowledgeable about these things?

If however Moonshift calls in the debt, taking charge of the share ownership by acquiring ICI would settle the £5m debt in full.

I can only hazard guess at what happens in the event of an Administrator taking control but as far as I understand things the shareholders lose their rights immediately?  If so and Moonshift not calling in their debt - they would be presumably in a position to serve notice to take over ICI Ltd and I guess if there are insufficient funds there, they simply go after the Director for the balance if the company is found to be trading whilst insolvent?

Ken still has a secured £5m in the club (which on paper at least seems to be his personal money?) so he would be in a position to fulfil that obligation if necessary?

 

I'm sorry that I am unable to give a definitive answer to your question and hopefully others who are more knowledgeable on these matters can add to/shoot down to my reply above, whichever is the most relevant to do so.

One small item of interest whilst I was researching the facts to answer your query was an article by Iles dated 10th September, which included this sentence -

"The funding gap for the next 12 months, taking into consideration only those debts which are due and outstanding bills, is thought to be close to £13m". 

I'm not intending to be an apologist for Anderson but it wasn't any secret that he was not funding the club from his personal wealth and with a £13m black hole in funding to plug, then is it really such a big surprise that players, HMRC and everybody else ended up not getting paid and the club looking to move into Administration 8/9 months later?

https://www.theboltonnews.co.uk/news/16833145.bolton-wanderers-set-for-administration/

 

Thank you very much for such a detailed answer. It's reassured me in a funny way as I worried when I asked the question that I was simply being dim in still not being sure what had happened, but reading your account I feel better as I'll bet I'm not the only one that hadn't followed all of this. 

I'm going to read this again now, sit down in a darkened room and see if I've got it fully worked out but until then thanks again. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Mounts Kipper said:

Really!! GTF any crest any colour, they can put Chinese writing in the players undies for all I care. 

What's point then? Lose your identity and what's next, move it to another town? Well they weren't arsed when we changed their heritage and our surveys show we'd make more money in x place than Bolton so we'll shift it all. Fuck that.

Edited by Marc505
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Mantra said:

The kit change wouldn’t bother me too much but the name change would be a bit different. However as long as it had Bolton in the name not much of a big deal. 

Like when Hull’s owner wanted to change from Hull City to Hull Tigers. I get why people made a fuss over it but with owners like Oyston and Anderson around, I don’t think changing our name to Bolton Lions is the worst thing that could happen to us. And of course it could always be changed back. Anyway getting a bit ahead of ourselves. Getting taken over by super rich Chinese is unlikely in itself, one step at a time, then we can argue about the cost of our identity...

To be fair yeah we're more likely to be taken over by the pop man than this lot so it's pointless worrying. Rola Cola Wanderers.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Moderators
1 hour ago, Mounts Kipper said:

I’d doubt they’d be doing that business on BWFC property.

Prob not, just thinking up scenarios which don't get my hopes up

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The very thought of anyone with a couple of quid to their name let alone this mob interested in taking us on fills me with scepticism, fear and basically a ‘will they bollocks’ attitude

beaten down by all this I just can’t get excited about anything or anyone 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

47 minutes ago, Marc505 said:

What's point then? Lose your identity and what's next, move it to another town? Well they weren't arsed when we changed their heritage and our surveys show we'd make more money in x place than Bolton so we'll shift it all. Fuck that.

I’ll worry about that if and when the Chinese takeover and if your wild scenario ever came to fruition. 

Edited by Mounts Kipper
Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, barrycowdrill said:

The very thought of anyone with a couple of quid to their name let alone this mob interested in taking us on fills me with scepticism, fear and basically a ‘will they bollocks’ attitude

beaten down by all this I just can’t get excited about anything or anyone 

This!! Well said

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.