Wanderlust Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 13 minutes ago, Eddie said: Going round in circles. I’m positive, you’re not. Agree to disagree I'm positive it's Schumacher's team, that's for sure. I'm only at "hopeful" on the "will he get us promoted" question though. Quote
boltonboris Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 34 minutes ago, gonzo said: we really aren't far off with a team full of lads who hadn't even met eachother a few weeks ago. It'll be reet. That's not exclusive to us though. Every fan base in the league will be saying the same - 10+ players per team, per summer is completely normal. We're not the only team waiting for things to 'click' Quote
Tombwfc Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 1 hour ago, Eddie said: To be honest, I don’t actually give a shit. You can either find all the reasons to be negative, add them together and write the season off after 6 games, or you can have a bit of balance, believe things are going in the right direction but aren’t perfect and at least have some hope and optimism for a season that has just hit September. I’ll have the latter. Last bit on this as I've said more than enough. But at no point have I ever written off the season or said anything like it. In fact, I think there's more than enough talent in the squad and we have more than enough resources to get promoted this season. Nigh on every team that gets promoted from L1 does so in their managers first full season so this is as good a time as any. That's not a prediction either way, it's just what I think is a very attainable target. But that actually makes me more positive than folk who think we have to wait another year before we can expect to properly compete in the third tier. Quote
Casino Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 1 minute ago, Tombwfc said: But that actually makes me more positive than folk who think we have to wait another year before we can expect to properly compete in the third tier. thats just getting excuses in early Quote
Wanderlust Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 8 minutes ago, Casino said: thats just getting excuses in early Exactly. Excuses like Schumacher hasn't got his own squad yet whatever that's supposed to mean. Quote
Eddie Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 56 minutes ago, Tombwfc said: Last bit on this as I've said more than enough. But at no point have I ever written off the season or said anything like it. In fact, I think there's more than enough talent in the squad and we have more than enough resources to get promoted this season. Nigh on every team that gets promoted from L1 does so in their managers first full season so this is as good a time as any. That's not a prediction either way, it's just what I think is a very attainable target. But that actually makes me more positive than folk who think we have to wait another year before we can expect to properly compete in the third tier. Fair enough. I don’t think we’re actually thinking too differently. I expect us to go up this year, I absolutely don’t think we need to wait another year and I’d be critical of SS if we don’t (certainly if we were to say miss the play offs). I think I’m just less critical of these first 6 games because I do consider them as completely separate to last year, whereas you’re probably a bit more critical because you take last year into account. Quote
frank_spencer Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 1 hour ago, Wanderlust said: Exactly. Excuses like Schumacher hasn't got his own squad yet whatever that's supposed to mean. By the end of today we can't blame the lineup for any failings. If a gap was that obvious in the tram then he's had time to fix it. If plan A gets injured then it's a different story. But his team Vs Orient should be exactly what he wants it to be. Quote
meanderson93 Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 12 minutes ago, frank_spencer said: By the end of today we can't blame the lineup for any failings. If a gap was that obvious in the tram then he's had time to fix it. If plan A gets injured then it's a different story. But his team Vs Orient should be exactly what he wants it to be. How you can possibly expect a full squad to be replaced in one window, especially at this level with the funds available I don't know. But sure, if people feel the need or desire to shorten their patience based on one transfer window then that's on them. I just think it's wholly unreasonable. Quote
frank_spencer Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 1 minute ago, meanderson93 said: How you can possibly expect a full squad to be replaced in one window, especially at this level with the funds available I don't know. But sure, if people feel the need or desire to shorten their patience based on one transfer window then that's on them. I just think it's wholly unreasonable. Not on about the full squad but his 1st 11 should be up to the job. We've signed eleventy wingers so that obviously something he saw was lacking. But other than Taylor he's not brought in any defensive players so either he thinks they're up to snuff or he's not recruited well enough. Quote
masi 51 Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 Same people who said Evatt should of stayed after 4 seasons in this league are now saying Schumacher should get it all right in one transfer window. I cannot hear any of them commenting on the 2m we have lost on sending two players out on loan Over to you lot.................................... Quote
Tombwfc Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 2 minutes ago, meanderson93 said: How you can possibly expect a full squad to be replaced in one window, especially at this level with the funds available I don't know. But sure, if people feel the need or desire to shorten their patience based on one transfer window then that's on them. I just think it's wholly unreasonable. Where has the expectation come from that we need to replace the full squad? I thought the way Evatt built the side was madness, but there was (and is) plenty of talent in there. Sheehan, Morley, Toal, Cogley etc. will continue to play not because SS is stuck with them, but because they're good players for this level. Quote
Zog1 Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 I figured out Evatt in our first year back in League One. Imagine how mental i was towards the end. SS needs to decide if he wants to die on the wingers cutting in on the inside to shoot non stop hill. If he doesn't stop that he's doomed, because it doesn't work and never would, prime Ronaldo couldn't do it never mind Gale or Duberry. Quote
frank_spencer Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 14 minutes ago, masi 51 said: Same people who said Evatt should of stayed after 4 seasons in this league are now saying Schumacher should get it all right in one transfer window. I cannot hear any of them commenting on the 2m we have lost on sending two players out on loan Over to you lot.................................... Evatt should've gone after Oxford. Quote
Ani Posted September 1, 2025 Author Posted September 1, 2025 2 minutes ago, Zog1 said: I figured out Evatt in our first year back in League One. Imagine how mental i was towards the end. SS needs to decide if he wants to die on the wingers cutting in on the inside to shoot non stop hill. If he doesn't stop that he's doomed, because it doesn't work and never would, prime Ronaldo couldn't do it never mind Gale or Duberry. What did you figure out about Evatt ? Quote
Zog1 Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 3 minutes ago, Ani said: What did you figure out about Evatt ? He couldnt read the game as it was happening, he was using the tactics of someone else that he didnt understand, he was applying PL tactics to L1 players. There's loads more. Quote
Wanderlust Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 (edited) 1 hour ago, masi 51 said: I cannot hear any of them commenting on the 2m we have lost on sending two players out on loan Over to you lot.................................... Exactly how have we lost any money at all on those two players? Also why £2 million And it was Schumacher’s decision to loan them out wasn’t it? Edited September 1, 2025 by Wanderlust Quote
gonzo Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 2 hours ago, Zog1 said: He couldnt read the game as it was happening, he was using the tactics of someone else that he didnt understand, he was applying PL tactics to L1 players. There's loads more. Very nearly worked though despite off all that. Quote
Zog1 Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 37 minutes ago, gonzo said: Very nearly worked though despite off all that. It did, i said a few times that by adding a proper DM to that team in 22/23 or 23/24 would have meant us going up, because they would have broken up play and sped up transitions. The thing is, i knew he wouldn't because he was arrogant and because his own football knowledge was limited he just couldn't see it. Quote
tomski Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 2 hours ago, Zog1 said: It did, i said a few times that by adding a proper DM to that team in 22/23 or 23/24 would have meant us going up, because they would have broken up play and sped up transitions. The thing is, i knew he wouldn't because he was arrogant and because his own football knowledge was limited he just couldn't see it. How he fucked it up is beyond belief. He blew our easiest ever chance. Quote
Traf Posted September 1, 2025 Posted September 1, 2025 Evatt failed to get us promoted from a shit L1. Therefore he underachieved. Quote
Zico Posted September 2, 2025 Posted September 2, 2025 6 hours ago, Traf said: Evatt failed to get us promoted from a shit L1. Therefore he underachieved. Also have to remember promotion was our stated aim, everything was geared towards it, including assembling (in his words) the best footballing team in the division Quote
Wanderlust Posted September 2, 2025 Posted September 2, 2025 8 hours ago, Traf said: Evatt failed to get us promoted from a shit L1. Therefore he underachieved. True. Him and 20 other managers failed in that league. Quote
Rival Son Posted September 2, 2025 Posted September 2, 2025 53 minutes ago, Wanderlust said: True. Him and 20 other managers failed in that league. How many of those 20 other managers failed for four seasons on the bounce? Quote
Traf Posted September 2, 2025 Posted September 2, 2025 1 hour ago, Wanderlust said: True. Him and 20 other managers failed in that league. So because others also failed, it's OK that he did with one of the biggest budgets? That's one of the thing wrong with this country's sports, we accept failure too easily. Quote
Zico Posted September 2, 2025 Posted September 2, 2025 2 hours ago, Wanderlust said: True. Him and 20 other managers failed in that league. this is only the case if you think that every club in every league sets out to win every game and their aim is the get promoted or win the title but it's not the case in reality the ones who failed will be the ones who had ambitions for a top 6 finish, but didn't make them, or lost in the play offs and the 4 that went down Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.